All Her Fault, the psychological thriller starring Sarah Snook, does not yet have an official second season on Prime Video. However, the series gained new momentum in January 2026, thanks to the award the protagonist received at the Critics Choice Awards. Therefore, the future of the production, which was developed as a miniseries and fully adapts Andrea Mara’s book, has become a major question mark. Meanwhile, Brazilian fans, who helped the title reach the platform’s Top 3, eagerly await a decision from the studios.
The phenomenon happened organically, growing through word of mouth on social media and becoming a frequent recommendation. Due to this quiet success, showrunner Megan Gallagher has already expressed interest in expanding the story’s universe. However, the main obstacle is narrative, as the mystery of Milo’s disappearance has been completely resolved. Thus, a possible continuation would need to create a new arc, perhaps focused on other characters or secrets of the community.
The signs that fuel fans’ hope
Despite being a closed story, the scenario for a second season of All Her Fault gained strength with Sarah Snook’s award. Furthermore, the solid performance on streaming, especially here in Brazil, is a crucial factor that platforms analyze. Therefore, the renewal window, which is usually 30 to 90 days after release, could be reopened by this new interest. In other words, continuous audience is the key to convincing Prime Video to invest in a new chapter.
It is worth noting that the series, with its eight episodes of about 50 minutes each, works perfectly as a standalone piece. It delivers tension, high-level performances, and a satisfying ending, without forced hooks. Still, the created universe is strong enough to support new stories. Thus, if the project moves forward, the expectation is that it will explore new family dilemmas with the same psychological depth that won over the audience.
While we await official confirmation, the complete first season is available in the Prime Video catalog for those who haven’t yet dived into this thriller. For those who have already finished, the tip is to spread the recommendation, as more views could be the final push the production needs. After all, in the world of streaming, numbers speak louder than any rumor.
