One Night in Idaho Season 2 Sets December 28 Premiere
Published on · Updated on
Prime Video sets One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer for December 28, with three episodes and investigators speaking out for the first time about the case.

Season two of One Night in Idaho premieres December 28, 2026, on Prime Video. Titled Catching a Killer, the new chapter of the documentary series runs three episodes and revisits the murders of four University of Idaho students in Moscow, Idaho, in 2022 — this time from the perspective of the police officers and investigators who worked the case and were barred from speaking for years by a gag order. The announcement came on November 18 alongside the official trailer and answers the main question left by season one: the follow-up exists, it has a date, and it changes the point of view.
When it premieres and where to watch
The date is December 28, a Monday. All three episodes arrive at once on Prime Video, a format that favors holiday binge-watching and repeats the full-season drop used for the first installment. The service is included with a Prime membership and can also be subscribed to separately; the series is available through the app and the web browser, with audio and subtitle options that vary by device.
The full title, One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer, keeps the brand of the original production while signaling the shift in focus. If 2025's The College Murders centered on the victims' families, the new season follows the people who ran the investigation — from the first patrol response to the operation that ended with the suspect's arrest in Pennsylvania.
Details about the date, format and team were confirmed in the official Prime Video release and on Amazon's news page. The exclusive announcement of the date and trailer was published by The Hollywood Reporter.
| Title | One Night in Idaho: Catching a Killer |
|---|---|
| Premiere | December 28, 2026 |
| Platform | Prime Video |
| Episodes | 3 |
| Director | Matthew Galkin |
| Showrunner | Katie A. King |
| Production | Amazon MGM Studios, Paramount Television Studios, Story Syndicate, James Patterson Entertainment and Fairhaven |
What the trailer reveals
The official trailer dropped the same day as the announcement and leans less on reenactments than on archival material. It opens with audio from a police call, followed by bodycam footage, interview-room recordings and first-person testimony from the investigators. The tone is clear: police procedure, public pressure and the emotional toll on the people who worked the case.
Official trailer for Catching a Killer
Prime Video released the season two trailer on November 18, 2026.
Watch the trailer on YouTube ↗In the footage, detectives stand before maps, photographs and evidence, reconstructing decisions that only became public after the sentencing. The material also returns to Moscow's grief and the media siege that turned a college town of roughly 25,000 people into a global focal point. The trailer makes a simple promise: to show what happened behind the scenes of an investigation that, for a long time, was told only through its results.
The investigators who can finally speak
The season's main asset is access to people who had never given interviews about the case. According to the producers, many were under a gag order and did not take part in other documentaries about the crimes. The list ranges from the detective who led the Moscow investigation to the police chief at the time, the first officers on the scene and the agents behind the breakthroughs: investigative genetic genealogy and the DNA collection in Pennsylvania.
- Brett Payne — lead detective on the case for the Moscow Police Department, joined by his wife, Alyson Payne;
- Darren Gilbertson — lead detective on the case for the Idaho State Police;
- James Fry — chief of the Moscow Police Department at the time;
- Mitch Nunes — the first officer to arrive at the scene and discover the bodies;
- Shaine Gunderson — the third officer to arrive at the scene;
- Jon Habben — FBI agent in Los Angeles who used investigative genetic genealogy to identify the suspect;
- Joe Traino — FBI agent in Pennsylvania who went undercover as a garbage collector to obtain genetic material from the Kohberger family home;
- Chris Paris — Pennsylvania State Police major who orchestrated the operation and the arrest.
Having several investigators in the same project is what sets this season apart from other productions about the case. Instead of rebuilding the crime from outside accounts, the series relies on the people who made operational decisions and on internal records such as forensic reports, police interviews and bodycam footage.
The case, from the murders to the conviction
In the early hours of November 13, 2022, four University of Idaho students were stabbed to death in an off-campus rental house in Moscow. Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves, both 21, and Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin, both 20, were found in different rooms. The lack of clear signs of forced entry and the violence of the attack fueled weeks of speculation.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| Nov 13, 2022 | Four students are killed in a rental house in Moscow, Idaho |
| Dec 30, 2022 | Bryan Kohberger is arrested at his parents' home in Pennsylvania |
| 2023–2025 | Prosecution and defense clash over evidence; genetic genealogy and DNA place the suspect at the center of the case |
| July 2025 | Kohberger pleads guilty and unsuccessfully tries to walk back the plea |
| July 23, 2025 | Sentencing: four consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole |
Kohberger was a criminology doctoral student at Washington State University in Pullman, about 15 kilometers from Moscow. He is serving his sentence at Idaho's maximum-security prison. The outcome — a conviction without trial, secured through a plea deal — is precisely the turning point that made season two possible, because it closed the criminal case and lifted the gag order that had constrained witnesses.
Who makes the series and what changes this season
Matthew Galkin directs. He co-directed season one with Liz Garbus, an Oscar nominee for I'll Be Gone in the Dark. Katie A. King is the showrunner. Executive producers are Galkin, Garbus, King, Dan Cogan, Jon Bardin, Joshua Levine, Tommy Coriale, James Patterson, Bill Robinson and Patrick Santa.
"The season delivers unprecedented, first-time exclusive access to the police and lead investigators closest to the Bryan Kohberger investigation, who carried the weight of a nation's obsession, and who, until now, were unable to tell their story under a gag order on the case."
The first season, released in 2025, debuted at number one on the platform and was defined by interviews with Stacey and Jim Chapin, Ethan Chapin's parents, and Karen and Scott Laramie, Madison Mogen's parents. The new season keeps in touch with family and friends but moves the narrative axis to the investigation. It is an editorial choice that widens the audience: it appeals to viewers who want a police procedural and to those who want to understand how the evidence was built.
The series arrives amid true-crime saturation, with dozens of productions about similar cases. The difference here is timing: the season became possible after the conviction, when investigators could speak without risking the trial — something the rival Peacock documentary, released in the same 2025 window, could not achieve on the same scale.
What to expect — and why the date matters
With three episodes, Catching a Killer has limited room and a defined focus: the manhunt. Expect a structure closer to a procedural thriller than to an intimate portrait of the victims, with attention to the investigation's early missteps, political pressure and the personal cost for the officers. For genre fans, the December 28 premiere is also a test of a model Prime Video keeps repeating: dropping everything at once, during the year's heaviest viewing period.
Season one remains available on the platform and works as a starting point for anyone who wants to understand the case before the new episodes. Those who already watched can revisit the material thinking about what was left out — and that is exactly where season two promises to go further, with the voices of the people who were at the scene, in the interview rooms and in the rooms where the investigation was assembled. Readers who want more context can browse the site's TV coverage and other true-crime documentaries that help explain the genre.